Menu of Shirley's Bar & Restaurant in Petersburg, Virginia, USA

Menu Overview

Shirley’s Bar & Restaurant, nestled in the historic heart of Petersburg at 20 W Tabb St, offers a compelling blend of Southern charm and culinary craftsmanship. The menu strikes a balance between comforting classics and elevated bar fare, anchored by fresh, vibrant ingredients and thoughtful preparation.

The appetizer selection sets a strong tone, with highlights like the Bread & Pimento and the Charcuterie Board, each promising rich flavors and excellent portion size. The Smoked Gouda Macaroni & Cheese stands out as a perfect comfort dish—creamy, smoky, and satisfyingly indulgent without being heavy. However, a recent experience with the West Shrimp Salsa Martini suggested some inconsistency; it arrived cold and lacked freshness, indicating it may have been pre-prepared, which detracts from the otherwise attentive quality.

Moving to the entrees and sandwiches, Shirley’s offers hearty, well-executed choices. The Southern Fried Chicken Sandwich and Southern Fried Chicken Fingers fulfill the expected crispy, flavorful Southern staple with a satisfying crunch and balanced seasoning. The Shirley’s Smashed Burger commands attention at $21, crafted with care and delivering robust, juicy satisfaction. Vegetarians will appreciate the Grilled Vegetable Ciabatta, which combines smoky, grilled produce with a fresh ciabatta roll, serving as a lighter, yet equally enjoyable option.

Soups and salads carry classic Southern undertones. The Southern Caesar salad is crisp and refreshing, with a creamy yet tangy dressing that complements the garden-fresh greens. The Creamy Tomato Bisque, priced economically at $7, offers a warming, robust experience, while the Composed Little Salad features a measured, elegant presentation suitable for those seeking a lighter fare.

What truly elevates Shirley’s is its bar program. Guests consistently praise the cocktail craftsmanship and friendly, knowledgeable bartenders like Sol and Jason, who bring creativity and local expertise to the drink menu. The inventive cocktails, including recommended house specialties not found on the printed menu, and a curated selection of local beers offer a perfect way to unwind. This spirited atmosphere complements both casual visits and special occasions.

The setting in a restored historic hotel contributes to an ambiance of old-world charm, reinforcing the dining experience with a sense of place unique to Olde Towne Petersburg. Whether for a quiet lunch, a celebratory dinner, or holiday meals such as Thanksgiving, Shirley’s delivers attentive service and a welcoming vibe, reflecting genuine pride in heritage and hospitality.

In summary, Shirley’s Bar & Restaurant blends Southern tradition with quality and care. While the lunch menu might benefit from a broader array and fresher execution on certain dishes, the overall flavor profiles, generous servings, and outstanding beverage program make it an appealing destination. The marriage of historic ambiance with solid culinary offerings creates a dining experience well worth exploring for both locals and visitors alike.